|
Thanks to the globally syndicated television program "BayWatch," Santa Monica Bay beaches are known around the world. Millions have seen that the Bay and its environs offer visitors a wide variety of recreational activities to choose from, including sunbathing, swimming, boating, playing volleyball, surfing, and cycling. More than 45 million people visit Santa Monica Bay beaches each year. On a hot summer weekend day, Bay beaches can provide cooling distractions for more than 500,000 visitors.
Along the Bay's 50-mile shoreline are 22 public beaches and a 22-mile bike path. Where does most of the action take place_ Of all the beaches in Los Angeles County, the beach at Santa Monica is the busiest.
Do Bay Waters Pose Health Risks_
Anecdotal reports from various sources, including the public, environmental organizations, and the news media say that swimmers get ear, eye, wound and intestinal infections, skin rashes and other illnesses as a result of contact with Bay waters.
One thing is clear: these reports of illness from swimming in the Bay have contributed to the public's concern about utilizing this most accessible recreational resource. Beach closures due to sewage spills and warnings of contaminated storm drain runoff have heightened our anxiety. Indeed, the Bay has developed a reputation for severe pollution -- an undeservedly extreme characterization of the Bay's pollution problems -- largely because of the continuing perception that swimming in the Bay is hazardous. A 1992 Santa Monica Bay Restoration Project (SMBRP) survey of 500 Los Angeles County adults showed that 41 percent of the public does not visit the Bay because of its concern about water pollution; many respondents claimed, "I might get sick if I swim in the water."
The SMBRP Epidemiology Study
In order to determine how safe it is to swim in Santa Monica Bay, the SMBRP launched a landmark epidemiological study in June of 1995. This "epi-study," completed in October 1995, is the only one of its kind to be conducted on the West Coast. Involving a wide variety of state and local agencies, the scientific community, and environmental organizations, it will provide the first-ever assessment of the potential health risks of swimming in Bay waters contaminated by urban runoff. (The study is also a vital component of the comprehensive Santa Monica Bay Restoration Plan.) Results of the study are expected to be released in May of 1996.
As part of the epi-study, water samples were collected for analysis at various places along the shoreline. In addition, some 13,000 beachgoers were interviewed to obtain information on their beach activities, including their swimming locations and the length of time they spent in the water. The respondents were contacted by telephone 9-14 days after the initial beach interviews so that follow-up information could be obtained about their health.
Pathogens Found in Bay Storm Drains
In previous studies, SMBRP researchers found evidence that pathogens (enteric viruses1 and possibly pathogenic bacteria) that may be carried by urban runoff through storm drains into the Bay could be responsible for adverse health effects. In dry-weather studies completed between 1989 and 1991, enteric viruses were found in the effluent in three separate locations: Pico-Kenter (Santa Monica) and Herondo (near Redondo Beach) storm drains and Malibu Lagoon. These outlets collect flow from scattered locations, and the watersheds they drain have all types of land uses.
This was a disturbing and curious finding, inasmuch as enteric viruses are associated with human excrement. Why would pathogens be present in the storm drain system, given that it is completely separate from the sewer system_ Possible sources include illegal sewer connections to the storm drain, leaking sewer lines, malfunctioning septic tanks, and inadequate waste disposal by recreational vehicles, campers or transients.
Several approaches to address pathogen contamination have been implemented while others are being investigated. One obvious and needed approach is to prevent pathogens and pathogen-contaminated runoff from entering the storm drain system in the first place.
Alternatively, pathogens in runoff can be diverted away from nearshore areas, as is the case at the Pico-Kenter storm drain, where the cities of Los Angeles and Santa Monica in 1992 agreed to begin treating the drain's dry-weather flow at the Hyperion Treatment Plant.
A third, ongoing approach is to minimize public exposure to pathogens with warnings and advisories. SMBRP has been instrumental in placing updated warning signs near storm drain outlets and advising beachgoers 1) not to swim within 100 yards of flowing storm drains; and 2) not to swim in the Bay during and for up to three days after a storm.
As long as swimmers abide by these warnings, the Bay's waters should be considered safe to swim in, and not a health risk from pathogens. Potential health risks associated with exposure to chemical contaminants are generally difficult to establish and are considered by public health officials to be relatively low. Obviously, this risk would be greater if a hazardous substance spill occurred.
|